NYC Toll Scams: Fake E-ZPass Texts

New York City’s new congestion pricing program is meant to reduce traffic in busy areas and improve air quality. However, scammers have quickly taken advantage of this change. They are sending fake E-ZPass messages that trick drivers into paying bogus tolls. In this article, we break down the congestion pricing plan, explain how these scams work, explore past examples of scams linked to policy changes, and offer clear advice on how you can protect yourself.

Introduction

New York City launched its congestion pricing program a few months ago to ease traffic and lower pollution in the city’s busiest areas. With this policy in place, drivers now face a toll charge when entering the congested zones. Unfortunately, scammers spotted an opportunity. Almost immediately, they began sending out fake messages that appear to come from E-ZPass. These messages claim that you owe unpaid tolls and urge you to pay immediately to avoid extra fees.

The scam is simple yet effective. The messages are short, use urgent language, and often include a link to a fraudulent website. Even people who do not own a car or an E-ZPass are getting these messages. In many cases, the texts claim you owe a small amount—around $6 or $7—to make the story seem believable. If you act quickly without verifying the information, you may end up sharing personal or financial details that can lead to identity theft or financial loss.

In the sections below, we explain how congestion pricing works, how scammers are exploiting this change, what similar scams have looked like in the past, and what experts and authorities are saying about the problem. We also provide practical tips to help you stay safe. Read on to learn how to protect yourself from these scams and understand why they are happening now.

Understanding NYC Congestion Pricing

Congestion pricing is a system designed to reduce traffic in busy urban areas. New York City has adopted this plan to cut down on the number of vehicles entering the city’s central business district. The goal is to improve traffic flow, lower pollution levels, and encourage people to use public transportation.

How It Works

• Toll Zones: Drivers entering certain parts of Manhattan are charged a fee. This fee varies based on the time of day and the type of vehicle.
• Payment Methods: Most drivers with an E-ZPass tag have their tolls deducted automatically. Those without an E-ZPass receive a bill in the mail.
• Policy Benefits: The revenue from these tolls is meant to support public transportation and infrastructure improvements, making travel smoother for everyone.

This new pricing system represents a significant shift in how New Yorkers travel and pay for road use. As a result, many people are still learning what to expect. This uncertainty creates the perfect environment for scammers to step in with fake messages and calls.

The Public’s Reaction

The introduction of congestion pricing has sparked mixed reactions. Many drivers welcome the idea as a way to reduce traffic congestion and improve the environment. Others are concerned about the added cost and potential errors in billing. As a result, official communications from agencies like the MTA and E-ZPass have been extensive, explaining how the system works and reassuring the public about the billing process.

Unfortunately, scammers exploit this confusion. They send out messages that mimic official alerts, hoping that people who are still adjusting to the new system will fall for the ruse. This overlap between genuine policy changes and fraudulent messages makes it crucial for drivers to know the difference.

How the Scams Work

Scammers use both text messages (smishing) and phone calls (vishing) to reach potential victims. Their tactics are straightforward: they create a sense of urgency and fear, prompting quick action without proper verification.

The Process

1. Unsolicited Messages: You receive a text message that appears to come from E-ZPass or another toll agency. The message states that you owe unpaid tolls for entering the congestion zone.
2. Urgent Language: The text warns that if you do not pay immediately, you may incur extra charges or fines. This urgency is designed to prevent you from taking time to think or verify the claim.
3. Suspicious Links: The message usually includes a link that looks official but leads to a fraudulent website. The site may ask you to enter personal information or credit card details.
4. Fake Contact Information: In some cases, scammers provide phone numbers that are not connected to any legitimate agency. They may even follow up with calls to reinforce the message.

Why It Works

Scammers use active language to create fear and prompt immediate action. Phrases like “pay now” or “avoid late fees” make it seem as if you are in imminent danger of financial penalties. The use of a small fee (around $6 or $7) adds credibility, as it seems like a minor mistake that needs quick correction.

Even if you are not a driver or do not have an E-ZPass, your phone number might have been obtained through data breaches or other scams. Once scammers have your contact details, they send out messages en masse, hoping that someone will respond.

Real-Life Examples

• Example 1: John, a New Yorker, received a text early one morning that said he owed an unpaid toll fee. The message warned him of increasing penalties and provided a link for payment. Trusting the message, John clicked the link, which led to a site asking for his bank details. Only later did he learn that the message was fake.
• Example 2: Maria, who does not own a car, also received a similar text. She was confused because she had no record of ever using E-ZPass. After a quick online search, she realized the message was a scam and reported it to local authorities.
• Example 3: In another case, a group of drivers received phone calls from someone claiming to be from the MTA. The caller insisted that their toll account was in arrears and that they needed to confirm their personal information. The language was aggressive, and the call ended abruptly when the victim questioned the details.

By using these tactics, scammers create a sense of panic that often leads people to act without checking the facts. This is why it is important to understand how these scams work and to always verify any messages with official sources.

Historical Context: How Policy Changes Fuel Scams

Scammers have a long history of taking advantage of policy changes and government announcements. Whenever there is confusion or uncertainty, fraudsters see an opportunity. Here, we explore a few past examples that mirror the current congestion pricing scams.

Stimulus Payment Scams

When governments announce stimulus payments, scammers jump at the chance. During the COVID-19 pandemic, many people received texts and emails claiming they were due extra funds from the IRS. The messages used urgent language to persuade recipients to click on links that led to phishing websites. These scams aimed to steal personal and financial information by posing as official notices.

Healthcare and Insurance Scams

The rollout of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) also brought about a wave of scams. As many Americans tried to understand the new system, fraudsters sent out messages claiming that individuals needed to verify their insurance details or update their information. These messages often contained links to fake websites designed to capture sensitive data. The confusion over the new healthcare system made it easier for scammers to slip in their fraudulent messages.

Tax Reforms and Filing Season Scams

Tax season has always been a busy time for scammers. After major tax reforms or when new tax credits are announced, many people receive emails and texts about refunds or extra credits. These messages typically use urgent language, warning of penalties if the information is not updated immediately. In 2022, after several tax law changes, the IRS reported a significant rise in smishing attempts where scammers sent fraudulent messages about tax refunds. These scams often resulted in identity theft and financial loss for many unsuspecting victims.

Global Crises and Emergency Scams

Natural disasters and global crises create an environment of fear and uncertainty, which scammers exploit ruthlessly. For example, during major hurricanes or after large-scale natural disasters, fraudsters send out fake donation requests and emergency relief offers. In each case, scammers take advantage of the public’s desire to help or get accurate information in a crisis. These scams are not limited to any one area; they have been seen across the globe, adapting their tactics to match the current crisis.

The Common Playbook

Across all these scenarios, scammers follow a similar playbook:

• Create Urgency: They use language that makes you feel like you must act immediately.
• Exploit Uncertainty: They take advantage of any confusion caused by new policies or emergencies.
• Imitate Official Communications: They mimic the style of real government messages or agency notifications.
• Collect Personal Data: Their main goal is to trick you into giving up sensitive information or making payments.

The congestion pricing scams in NYC follow this same pattern. Scammers see the new policy as a chance to prey on confusion and fear. By mimicking official messages from E-ZPass or the MTA, they deceive many people into thinking the threat is real.

Official Warnings and Expert Opinions

City and state officials, along with cybersecurity experts, have responded quickly to the rise in toll scams. They have issued public warnings and provided clear guidance on how to spot fake messages. Understanding their advice can help you protect yourself.

Government and Agency Alerts

• Governor’s Warning: Governor Kathy Hochul has publicly warned New Yorkers about the fake E-ZPass messages. She stressed that official agencies will never ask for payment or personal information via unsolicited text messages or phone calls.
• MTA and E-ZPass Statements: Both the MTA and E-ZPass have released statements confirming that they do not send out messages requesting payment or personal details. They emphasize that all official communications will come from their verified channels.
• Consumer Protection Agencies: The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and the FBI have both issued alerts. The FTC’s consumer alert, titled “Got a text about unpaid tolls? It’s probably a scam,” explains that no government agency will ask for sensitive information in this manner. The FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) also encourages anyone who has received a suspicious message to report it immediately.

Expert Insights

Cybersecurity experts warn that scammers use simple yet effective tactics to catch victims off guard. They note that:

• Simple Tricks Work Best: Scammers use everyday language and small fee amounts to seem believable.
• Urgency is Key: The messages create a false sense of urgency to force victims into quick action.
• Mimicking Trusted Brands: By using names like “E-ZPass” and “NY Toll Services,” scammers benefit from the public’s trust in these institutions.
• Patterns of Behavior: Experts have seen similar scams in other parts of the country during tax season and after major government announcements. These patterns show that scammers will keep adapting their methods to suit current events.

One cybersecurity analyst explained, “When people are already confused by new policies, they are more likely to act without verifying the source. Scammers take advantage of this vulnerability.” This statement highlights why public education and awareness are so critical in fighting these scams.

How to Protect Yourself from Toll Scams

The best defense against these scams is to be informed and cautious. Here are some practical tips to help you stay safe:

Verify Before You Act

• Double-Check the Source: If you receive a text or call about unpaid tolls, do not rely on the message alone. Visit the official E-ZPass or MTA website to check your account status.
• Contact Official Channels: Call the official customer service number for E-ZPass (for example, 1-800-333-8655) or the MTA directly. Do not use any contact information provided in a suspicious message.

Be Cautious with Links and Attachments

• Avoid Clicking on Unfamiliar Links: If a message includes a link, hover over it (or tap and hold on your mobile device) to see the actual URL. If it does not match the official website, do not click it.
• Do Not Download Attachments: Scammers may send attachments that contain malware or viruses. Only open attachments from trusted sources.

Recognize Urgent Language and Red Flags

• Watch Out for Pressure Tactics: Scammers use urgent phrases like “act now” or “avoid penalties” to rush you into making a mistake.
• Look for Poor Spelling or Grammar: Official messages from agencies like the MTA or E-ZPass are usually well-written. Mistakes can be a sign of fraud.
• Check the Sender’s Information: If the message comes from an unfamiliar number or email address, be suspicious. Official agencies use specific, verified contact details.

Report Suspicious Messages

• Forward Suspicious Texts: You can forward any spam or suspicious text messages to 7726 (which spells SPAM) to help carriers identify and block scammers.
• File a Complaint: Report the scam to the FTC via reportfraud.ftc.gov or file a complaint with the FBI’s IC3 at ic3.gov.
• Inform Local Authorities: Let your local police department know if you believe you have been targeted by a scam. This helps build a case against the fraudsters.

Stay Updated

• Follow Official Social Media: Agencies such as the MTA, E-ZPass, and local government offices often post scam alerts and safety tips on their social media channels.
• Subscribe to Alerts: Sign up for email or SMS alerts from trusted government agencies. This way, you receive verified information directly.
• Educate Yourself: Regularly review news articles and official statements about toll scams and other related threats. Staying informed is one of the best defenses.

By following these steps, you can protect your personal information and help reduce the success rate of these scams.

What You Should Do If You Become a Victim

Even with the best precautions, some people might still fall for a scam. If you suspect that you have become a victim, here are the immediate steps you should take:

Act Quickly

• Contact Your Bank or Credit Card Company: Let them know that you might have shared your financial information with a scammer. They can monitor your account for suspicious activity.
• Change Your Passwords: Update any passwords that might have been compromised. Use strong, unique passwords for each account.
• Monitor Your Accounts: Keep a close eye on your bank accounts and credit reports for any unusual transactions. If you see any unauthorized charges, report them immediately.

Report the Incident

• File a Report with Local Law Enforcement: This can help build a case against the scammers and potentially prevent future attacks.
• Notify the FTC and FBI: Use the FTC complaint system or the FBI’s IC3 portal to file a report. The more reports they receive, the better they can track and shut down these scams.

Get Professional Help

• Seek Guidance from a Cybersecurity Expert: If you are unsure about the steps to take, consider consulting a professional who can help secure your devices and personal information.
• Contact a Consumer Protection Agency: Agencies like the Better Business Bureau (BBB) can offer advice and help guide you through the process of recovery.

Taking swift action can minimize the damage and help you regain control of your personal information.

‍